On October 4, 2011, moms arrived at the third of four Tween Academy classes ready to talk about communicating with tweens – and it was a HOT topic. Questions, ideas and suggestions flew during the hour-long discussion.
The class was led by Rosalind Wiseman, parenting expert and New York Times bestselling author of Queen Bees and Wannabes, along with six blogger co-hosts. Rosalind will also be appearing on Anderson Cooper’s Town Hall show to talk about bullying on Oct. 9 and 14 at 8 p.m. ET, so check your local listings!
As a parent, it can be easy to think your child isn’t listening to you, but they are, and they need to know that you’re listening, too. According to the Unilever Tween Confidence Index, commissioned by fabulous Tween Academy sponsor Unilever’s partnering deodorant brands, the more tweens value talking to their parents, the higher self-confidence they’ll have.
But when it feels like they are disregarding your every word, it helps to get some sympathy and suggestions from other parents. As Dana said during the chat, it’s “nice to get ideas and know that you are not alone in the tween/teen zone.”
To be part of an ongoing discussion, you can visit Don’t Fret the Sweat on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/#!/DontFretTheSweat
And join us next week, October 11 at noon ET, to discuss Tweens and Building Self-Esteem!
Keeping Open Lines of Communication
Focus on listening. Often children confide in their parents to vent, not to get advice. Unless there is immediate physical danger, when your child tells you something, really listen. Many children are reluctant to share problems with their parents because they’re worried their parents will “freak out.”
Start with the small stuff. If you can talk to your kids at the start of puberty about growth spurts, body odor and deodorant, they will come to you later for bigger life moments and issues. Supporting research shows that confidence and self-esteem begins to decline as tweens transition to their teenage years (age 13-17), underscoring the importance of continual communication.
Thank them for sharing their problem with you. Reaching out to their parents is difficult for many kids, so it’s important to recognize this effort as you want to be a resource for your child in the future.
Overcoming Communication Challenges
Parents worry about a number of issues when it comes to communicating with their kids as they grow older and become quieter and less open.
“Keeping the honesty going is what I worry about,” said 1MomJustSaying, and Kailani at An Island Life said she struggles with “just getting my daughter to open up and talk to me.”
Dana sympathized, “Sometimes I wonder if he even hears me. I just get a blank look.”
You can find creative solutions to get through to your tween. Suggested Michele at Scraps of My Geek Life, “I use the technology to my advantage! Sometimes it’s easier for them to communicate using the phone so we text!”
And Kayla S had a low-tech version of the same idea. “Before cell phones (*GASP*), my mother and I would write letters to each other when the communication was hard,” she said. “That way, you can focus on what you want to say and get it out easier. It gives you time to think.”
To get kids to talk in more than a single syllable, “ask open ended questions. Not a yes or no answer. That helps us a ton,” said Carmen at Mom to the Screaming Masses. A few examples from the community:
Who did you sit with at lunch?
What did your teacher say about this?
Who ran with you in cross-country practice?
Did you have band today?
Do you like this band teacher more than the one last year?
How was your day?
Did you do anything fun?
And a few suggestions from Rosalind Wiseman, who asks “something specific but not oriented toward a task or achievement” to get her kids talking:
Anything unusually interesting happen today?
What was the weirdest thing that happened in school today?
What was the most interesting or surprising thing on the test?
“I get better answers when I’m more specific,” agreed Michele at Scraps of My Geek Life.
If the kids are being really unresponsive, “sometimes you just have to take a break. You know how sometimes you don’t want to talk with your hubby, but later it’s ok?” explained Carmen at Mom to the Screaming Masses.
Letting Tweens Know You’re on Their Side
Our kids often don’t understand that we are thinking of their best interests when we ask them to do something. In many cases, opening up and laying your cards on the table might be the very thing that convinces them that you’re trying to help.
To illustrate, Rosalind shared an example of how her 11-year-old son refused to shower one day. Finally, she told him, ‘Look, you and I will have about a million battles of wills in my lifetime. This shouldn’t be one of them. I am saying this to you because your body is changing, you need to take care of yourself, and you know that X kid in your class loves to tease people about anything he can and this is one of the ways kids embarrass each other. So this is not a battle of wills between you and me.’ Then she left. It worked – he took a shower.
“Those conversations usually start when I lay it all out and say, ‘here’s the deal….’” agreed Deborah.
“I LOVE that. So important to let them know that you’re on the same team,” said Becky Gillespie.
“Plus you walked away and let him internalize it – made it into his decision instead of forcing him ‘at gunpoint,’ so to speak,” added Sarah Auerswald.
Don’t make every teaching moment a battle of wills, and recognize when you and your tween have stopped listening to each other. “That’s the kind of honesty – about listening – that kids love. Some people worry that this takes away from our authority as parents. I disagree. I think it really shows them how and why to respect us as their parents,” said Rosalind Wiseman.
Competing with Technology for Attention
Cell phones and other technology can be one major battle of wills in the parent-tween relationship. While some moms use them to get kids’ attention and communicate, others struggle with tearing their tweens away from the devices.
“We prohibit texting one another in the house. We feel it doesn’t foster good conversations,” said Kristin at Only Parent Chronicles.
And Carmen at Mom to the Screaming Masses cited “getting my kids to put down the phones and listen to ME” as a communication barrier.
Sometimes you have to fight fire with fire. “If they keep looking at their phone, text them something like, ‘What’s so interesting?’ or repeat your actual question in a text. They may laugh it off and set the phone down,” suggested Dwan at Momma D Jane.
“I do find that when the cell phone is left at home, like on a family outing, we have a much better time,” Sandra said of her daughter. “She is more aware of her surroundings and participates with the family instead of being a by-stander with fingers glued to the phone.”
Make sure your kids are old enough to use a cell phone responsibly before rewarding them with one.
Rosalind Wiseman said, “I don’t think children should have cell phones until they are consistently going places on their own. When they go into large groups of people (concerts, an event the family goes to) I think it makes sense for kids to carry a cell phone [for safety], but that doesn’t mean they have to have their own.”
Privacy is a Privilege
When your kids do start using cell phones and open a Facebook account, you can – and often should – monitor their behavior.
“My twelve year old son has a cell phone, and I have told him that his texts are not private and I will periodically review them. I feel very uncomfortable doing this, but I feel less comfortable with him engaging in these kinds of communications without any supervision,” said Meryl.
Kristin at Only Parent Chronicles responded, “My kids got their cell phones with the understanding I could view their texts on demand. My daughter lost hers a year ago for sending inappropriate texts bullying another girl.”
Heather G laid ground rules right away when her daughter got a cell phone: “Phone stays off after 8pm in the kitchen, no Internet, no MMS (pictures), we have the right at any time to read her texts, we approve all address book adds.”
Some moms reported that their kids began deleting texts as soon as sending or receiving them to avoid punishment. Michele at Scraps of My Geek Life noted, “I told my kids that NOTHING is ever completely erased from their phones even when you hit delete.”
When it comes to Facebook, “My kids have to wait until 13,” said Carmen at Mom to the Screaming Masses, which is the age stipulated by Facebook’s Terms of Service. “And I have your password until you are old enough to demonstrate you can be adult enough about it, and I’ve changed the password if someone needs to be reminded to behave appropriately.”
Jen at Jael Custom Designs said, “Facebook is another way I’ve caught my kids. I’ve had to tell them to erase a few status updates. I closely monitor those as well.”
Rosalind Wiseman summed it up when she said, “If you use social networking like FB, FB says ‘connecting you to the world.’ It doesn’t say, ‘connecting you to everyone but the people you don’t want to see your postings on a moment to moment basis.’ If your child wants privacy, give them a journal and tell them to put it under their bed.”
Tough Conversations
Puberty, privacy, simply getting your kids to open up about their lives – those are all tough conversations, as are many topics you address with tweens. But there are other conversations to consider that may be a bit more off the beaten path.
“The most difficult thing for me is getting them to see where they’ve made a mistake. My kids are stubborn and never, ever wrong,” joked Carmen at Mom to the Screaming Masses.
And Kristin at Only Parent Chronicles said, in a similar vein, “The most difficult conversations to have with my kids revolve around personal accountability.”
No one loves to admit they were wrong or take the blame for their actions, but it is an important part of growing up. Sometimes tough love is the only way to get that message across.
“I was always worried about my son getting bad grades, so I would run his book to school that he left at home, or I would over-help on a project,” said Dana. “Then I got tired of him not learning or even being appreciative of what I was doing, so I stopped. It was really hard, but after facing a couple of tough consequences he did finally start to show more responsibility and appreciation.”
Being There When They Need You
Sometimes your children will be visibly upset but refuse to tell you what’s wrong. It can be especially hard to face an uncommunicative tween when tears are involved.
“My daughter will be obviously upset about something – crying even – and sit there and tell me everything’s fine. I don’t want to push too hard, but yet, how do I get her to open up in those moments? Or do I wait ‘til she’s ready to come to me?” said Brandie.
The group consensus was “leaving her alone for awhile but letting her know I’m there whenever she wants to talk. Works 99% of the time,” as indiana said.
“I often will just sit with them. Quietly – no questions. It has worked a few times,” added Deborah.
Sometimes it’s better to let them be. “I leave her alone for awhile and let her cry it out. I found she is more responsive to talking after she gets the tears out,” said Jeannine M.
Rosalind Wiseman suggested saying, “’Look, I respect your privacy, and I can’t make you tell me. I just want you to know everyone at some point has a problem that is too big to deal with alone. And asking for help or talking to someone is not weak. If you can’t talk to me, is there some other person who you think is smart enough and I think has good values, that you can talk to? Like my sister, brother, mom, favorite neighbor across the street, etc.’”
Agreed Jen at Jael Custom Designs, “My kids are good about going to an aunt or uncle to talk if they don’t want to open up to me about a particular subject. Sometimes I’m bothered by it, but at least they’re talking AND my sister and brother-in-laws always keep me in the loop.”
Keeping Your Cool
When your kids finally start talking, you might not be thrilled with what they have to say. But a big negative reaction will only make them clam up again.
“I’ve had to practice not overreacting with my teen when she tells me ‘not so great’ stories about some of her friends. This has helped her continue to open up to me and discuss their actions,” said Dwan at Momma D Jane.
“When I’m angry, I talk at them and not to them and that results in not being a good listener,” added Jen at Jael Custom Designs.
Suggested 1MomJustSaying, “We have learned that controlling one’s tone when speaking is the key to keeping the conversation from escalating to an aggressive state.”
And while it can be tough to swallow, remember that your kids won’t always agree with you. “It seems like as my daughter gets older, I lose a little credibility because she is exposed to other people’s opinions. That is a good thing and I want her to form her own opinions, but I guess I don’t want to feel like she disregards my opinions,” said Kate B. “Staying a trusted confidante without going too much into friend territory is something I worry about sometimes.”
Remembering Not to Limit Communication
You can remain a trusted confidante by being open to talking about anything and everything with your tween, and not telling them to stop when they open up.
“I have trained myself to listen to EVERY story my 12 yo daughter tells me. Even though it may be so boring and long winded,” said 1MomJust Saying. “My feeling is that if I stop her from talking then she will.”
If they’re shy, let them know they don’t have to tell you absolutely everything.
Rosalind Wiseman suggested, “For private kids I always tell them that they don’t have to tell me 100% but if they could give me 30% that would be awesome. I also think it is really important to overwhelm them with questions. If they have a hard time with something and are telling you the MOST important thing to say is ‘I am so sorry that happened to you, thank you for telling me and together we are going to think this through.’”
And while you should always be a parent to your child rather than their friend, your relationship doesn’t have to be lopsided.
Said Becky Gillespie, “My best tool with my daughter is when we’re able to share a level playing field – we both have something to add and she doesn’t feel like it’s another lecture. Books are huge for us. We read the same book, then talk about it.”
Resources
Sandra shared an article on raising girls: http://www.dotcomsformoms.com/10-top-resources-for-raising-girls
From Carmen at Mom to the Screaming Masses – create a Mind Jar to help your kids de-stress: http://www.herewearetogether.com/?p=2054
Nails in the Fence – a story to help your kids understand that angry words hurt: http://www.care2.com/greenliving/nails-in-fence-anger-story.html
Thank you!!!
A BIG thanks to Rosalind Wiseman to lending her parenting expertise to our Tween Academy classes, and to Unilever for being our sponsor and making this all possible! Another thank-you to our fabulous blogger co-hosts:
Carmen, Mom to the Screaming Masses
Jen, Jael Custom Designs
Michele, Scraps of My Geek Life
Kailani, An Island Life
Kristin, Only Parent Chronicles
Dwan, MommaDJane
Don’t Fret the Sweat on Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/#!/DontFretTheSweat
See the original Talk here: http://tmotherhood.wpengine.com/talk/show/id/62266